Dance news, reviews & info

The final episode of BBC 4’s documentary about the English National Ballet focused on their Christmas production of The Nutcracker. The company may have been bringing seasonal joy and cheer to their audiences, but backstage there was certainly nothing festive about the mood of the company.

This episode revealed a tired company who appeared to have little drive or passion and despite the much calmer Wayne Eagling choreographing the ballet rather than the bullish Derek Deane, it still made for uncomfortable viewing.

Choreographically the series has portrayed three very different styles. From the bullying tactics of Derek Deane, which it has to be said does get results, to the kind but firm approach of Patricia Ruanne and finally the eccentric, creative but completely disorganised process favoured by Wayne Eagling.

Although I’m sure for the dancers Wayne is less scary to work with than Derek, his way of choreographing has the most negative effect on the dancers out of all the three choreographers portrayed.

Wayne Eagling rehearsing and choreographing at the same time. (Image - screenshot taken from BBC iplayer 'Agony and ecstasy for review purposes)

This week’s programme leaves you feeling physically stressed as you watch the dancers attempt to cope with last minute rehearsals and the crippling knowledge that they may go on stage without knowing the steps. For a dancer it is terrifying to be waiting in the wings unsure of whether you will remember the steps in front of the audience.

Normally a dancer relies on their muscle memory which will kick in even if they experience a moment where they ‘freeze’. However in my experience it takes at least a week of rehearsals for a dancer’s body to truly commit steps to its muscle memory. For the ENB dancers who were still learning steps hours before curtain up on first night, there was obvious dismay at how they were going to cope in front of an audience.

Corps de ballet member, Kasenia Ovsyanick, who has been chosen to dance The Dance of the Mirlitons comments that the attitude of the teachers and choreographer doesn’t help and that they aren’t trying to help the dancers. Kasenia is reduced to learning steps off a mobile phone video and practising in a fire exit despite the fact that her dance is very difficult and not even finished. Similarly Senior Principal Elena Glurdjidze says that she will be the one on stage, not the choreographer and asks how can she dance something correctly when she has never tried it before.

For Daria Klimentova, who admitted in the first episode that at the age of 38 she was dancing for the love and fun of it, rehearsing The Nutcracker certainly didn’t fit into this ideal. During the dress rehearsal, which was watched by a paying audience, Daria had to stop several times, both during her pas de deux and her solo. This highlights just how unprepared the company was feeling, as dancers rarely give up in front of an audience, especially a prima ballerina with years of experience like Daria.

Daria distressed after stopping during dress rehearsal. (Image - screenshot taken from BBC iplayer 'Agony and Ecstasy' for review purposes)

This last episode really highlighted an issue that has become more and more obvious as the series continued – The English National Ballet doesn’t appear to be a very happy company at the moment. The BBC has presented them as a downtrodden company with little artistic zeal. The dancers have come across as very passive with both Patricia Ruanne and Wayne Eagling making comments about their lack of participation.

Eagling remarked, ”The worst feeling in the world is to face a room full of people just looking at you going ok genius do something.” Maybe he should thank Derek Deane for making his dancers submissive! Rather than working with their choreographers and suggesting other ways of doing things the dancers simply wait to be told what to do. They are then shown shaking their heads between them incredulously at how long Eagling is taking to come up with steps. The company seems to be in dire need of more artistic injection from the dancers as well as the choreographers!

Perhaps the financial pressures of the company are weighing heavy on the dancers and impacting on their love of ballet. Fortunately when they are on stage none of this is evident and it will come as a surprise to the company’s followers that the company is so different off stage to on.

Another issue that the BBC concentrates on is the lack of cohesion between the dance side of the company and the supporting elements of the company such as the stage managers, the costume designers and the set designers. All too often in the ballet world these important supporting elements are taken for granted and the dancers and choreographers assume a superior role. This is clearly the case during this production and is exaggerated due to the time constraints experienced.

The costume designers who have obviously worked extremely hard under a lot of pressure are not given a voice and are visibly stressed at the lack of gratitude from Wayne. The shoe designer is left flabbergasted when Wayne decides that the rat king will wear ballet shoes and not the boots she has spent hours making. They are also brushed aside when they ask for a full rehearsal for the costume changes. In a similar vein the set designers are blamed for all manner of problems despite the fact that Britain has been hit by heavy snowfall which makes their job harder and the fact that they have not had time to rehearse the technical stunts.

The dancers put on an excellent first performance. (Image- screenshot from BBC iplayer for review purposes)

Fortunately the end result as always is beautiful. The dancers manage to put on a top class performance despite moments where they just have to improvise! There are stills of the dancers in the wings smiling but these little moments of happiness certainly don’t equate to ecstasy and don’t do much to outweigh the agony of rehearsing the ballet. When the dancers are taking their curtain call everyone is pleased except for Wayne Eagling who rather than praising the excellent work of his dancers, is obsessed with the fact that his hot air balloon trick didn’t work properly. No wonder the dancers look disillusioned when that is the response they get from their choreographer.

The programme is called Agony and the ecstasy but there is far more agony footage shown than ecstasy, possibly leaving viewers with a negative opinion of the ballet world. As ballet is in somewhat of a precarious situation with arts council cuts and new generations not attending theatre productions, shedding a negative light on the ballet world is not helpful. In my opinion the programme needed to highlight the joy of dancing and ask the dancers more about why they choose ballet as a career.

Watch episode 3 on BBC iplayer here


Comments on: "REVIEW Episode 3: Agony and the ecstasy: a year with the English National Ballet" (3)

  1. Cassie said:

    Well, the thing about ballet is that there are always situations like this! I’ve never had to dance on stage just learning steps hours earlier (except for once where I was last minute understudy and learned the piece the afternoon before) – but all of the scenes where Wayne kept stopping to “tweak” choreography? Totally been there.

    And though some dancers love the experimental-style of choreography (where choreographers just give them an idea or suggestions and the dancers kind of figure it out themselves) – I always hated that. Tell me what to do and I’ll do it. I mean, I could embellish or sort of expand on the choreography, but you have to give me specifics first 🙂

    As for Derek Deane and his style of choreographing/running rehearsals, I’ve seen plenty of that style too. Even when they are dealing with advanced students (high school age).

    But I agree – it was an uncomfortable episode. Even moreso than Episode 1 where though Deane was quite biting with his comments, I felt that some of the dancers deserved their tongue-lashing (Daria, for example, acts a bit too much like a brat – maybe given her seniority, she feels entitled to behave how she wants).

  2. As somebody knowing nothing about ballet I thought these programmes were amazing and as a result of watching have just booked my tickets for the Nutcracker.

    Your account of each programme was spot on. For me Daria was the star of the series.

  3. I just watched the re-run of this series on BBC4 (I missed it the first time) and went hunting for reviews to find out if anyone else was shouting at Wayne Ealing during this episode like I was.

    The reviews I could find focused on the first episode (Swan Lake) and compared the series to either Black Swan or Pineapple Dance Studios. I’m so glad that I found your blog and I think your review is spot on. I understood the choreography styles of Derek Deane and Patricia Ruanne, having had both types as dance teachers at some point, but Wayne Ealing had me stunned and furious in equal measure.

    If this is the future ballet companies face during cuts to the Arts budget, I’m worried for my favourite form of dance.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: